November 21, 2026

Cold-Curd Cottage Cheese

Milk was plentiful this summer, so I was able to expand my routine cheesemaking a bit. I prioritize cheeses needed until next spring when the goats freshen, cheeses such as mozzarella and halloumi (both of which I freeze), hard cheeses (stored in my solar fridge), and feta (which I store in herbed olive oil.) One that I was able to make this summer is cottage cheese. Dan loves it with pineapple, and this became a regular side dish for lunch. 

I'm calling this recipe "cold-curd" because I found myself experimenting to make it closer to what was familiar to us, i.e. store bought! Isn't it funny that grocery store quality is the standard for so many foods we learn to make ourselves? Even though I've incorporated a lot of new dishes and techniques into my cooking repertoire, some things just taste best when they meet the expectation of what we're used to. 

My cottage cheese recipe is based on Jerry Issa's 19 Easy Ways to Make Cheese and Yogurt (for Beginners), a free PDF download. It's truly an easy recipe. My batches are made with half-gallons of fresh morning milk, still warm from the goat. 

In a stainless steel pot mix:
  • half-gallon of body temperature milk
  • 2 tablespoons fresh kefir (or plain yogurt)
  • half dose of rennet 
Mix gently but well, then cover with a clean cotton dishcloth and let sit at room temperature until after lunch. By then, the curd is set and separated from the whey around the edges of the pot. Cut the curds (I use a whisk).


The next step for most cheeses is "cooking." This is where the fresh curds are left in the whey and heated to a little warmer than body temperature typically 110°F (43°C). They are stirred frequently to keep them from re-clumping. The idea here is to pull more whey from the soft curds to firm them up a bit. After about 30 minutes of cooking, they are drained and ready for the next step.

When I did that for cottage cheese, I thought the curds were a bit too firm. I was used to eating a softer curd cottage cheese, so I started to eliminate the cooking step. 

Draining the curds. I use unbleached muslin because common craft cheese cloth is too
 loosely woven. Butter muslin is recommended, but is expensive and must be ordered online.

After draining the curds, the next step is washing them. To do this, I fill the drained pot with cool water, and return the curds (still in the draining cloth) to the pot to rinse off the whey.

The draining cloth keeps the curds contained, so all I have to do is to
lift it out of the water, curds and all. I set it in a colander, pour out
the first rinse water, and fill the pot with fresh water a second rinse.

The curds get two rinses, draining well in between. 

Next the curds are salted to taste. For a half-gallon of milk, start with
  • half-teaspoon of your choice of salt
The salt will pull more whey from the curds so I let it drain a bit more. 

Lastly, because we like creamy cottage cheese, I add whatever cream I can skim off the half-gallon jars of goat milk in the fridge.
  • a couple tablespoons of cream, half-n-half, or milk, if desired
Fold in and store in the fridge in an air-tight container. 


It's about as close to what we're used to as we could wish. Actually, better because it's made from our own raw goat milk, plain and simple.

How about you? Have you been experimenting how to make something similar to the commercial products you grew up with? I'd be interested in what you've tried and what you've worked out. 

No comments: